MIRRORS OF THE PAST: REFLECTIONS OF HISTORY IN THE HISTORICAL PROSE OF WALTER SCOTT AND HILARY MANTEL
Abstract
The article is concerned with a comparative analysis of the works of two outstanding authors, each of whom has made their contribution to the genre of the historical novel. The research aims to highlight how Mantel and Scott approach the portrayal of historical events and figures, reflecting them through the lens of their own unique styles and historical interpretations. It also emphasizes that both writers utilize detailed historical accuracy as the foundation for their works, yet their methods of depicting characters and events differ. Walter Scott is known for his idealized and romanticized portrayal of the past, upholding national myths and striving to create an image of a polite nation. On the other hand, Hilary Mantel introduces a new level of psychological depth and moral complexity to the historical novel, presenting her characters in a more realistic and ambivalent light. The article analyzes differences in narrative structure, approaches to characters, and thematic emphases, focusing on how each author's writing technique creates their unique view of the past. Particular attention is paid to how Mantel uses a complex narrative structure with multiple timelines and points of view, while Scott favors a more traditional and linear narrative. Concluding with a discussion on the influence of both authors' works on modern historiography, the article provides a comprehensive look at how historical prose can simultaneously be a source of entertainment and a serious historical narrative. The result of the undertaken research not only identifies key commonalities and differences in the historical novels of Mantel and Scott but also emphasizes the timeless nature of the historical novel as a means to explore and understand the past.
Full text article
References
Arias R. Exoticizing the Past in Contemporary Neo-Historical Fiction, 2014, pp. 19–36. Available at: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9781137375209_2
Burrow C. London Review of Books. Available at: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v31/n08/colin-burrow/how-to-twist-a-knife
Dezorseva M. A. Filologicheskiy klass, 2019, No. 3(57), pp. 161–166.
Egorova L. V. Dva veka angliiskogo romana: kollektivnaya monografiya (Two centuries of the English novel: a collective monograph). Sankt-Peterburg, 2021, 368 p. DOI: 10.31425/0042-8795-2023-4-190-193
Erokhin V. N. Stanovlenie natsii. Religiozno-politicheskaya istoriya Anglii XVI – pervoi poloviny XVII v. v sovremennoi britanskoi istoricheskoi nauke (The formation of a nation. The religious and political history of England in the 16 – first half of the 17 century in modern British historical science). Moscow; Sankt-Peterburg: Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ, 2016, 752 p.
Juravleva O. A. Filologicheskiy klass, 2023, No. 2. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/poetika-sredney-linii-v-romanah-v-skotta (June 22, 2024).
Komarovskaya T. E. Istoricheskii roman SShA KhKh veka (A historical novel of the USA of the twentieth century). Minsk: BGPU, 2019, 236 p.
Lazareva T. G. Mirovaya literatura v kontekste kul'tury, 2014, No. 3(9), pp. 5–15.
Litvinenko N. A. Frantsuzskii istoricheskii roman pervoi poloviny XIX veka (A French historical novel of the first half of the 19th century). Moscow: URLO, 1999, 163 p.
Lortts I. Istoriya Tserkvi, rassmotrennaya v svyazi s istoriei idei (The history of the Church, considered in connection with the history of ideas). Moscow: Novoe vremya, 2000, 579 p.
Lukach G. Istoricheskii roman (A historical novel). Moscow: Common place, 2014, 178 p.
Mantel H. I Met a Man Who Wasn’t There: Lecture. The Huntington (May 19, 2017). Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEXatV1hqZo (June 22, 2024).
Mantel H. Wolf Hall. London: Fourth Estate, 2010, 653 p.
Orlov S. A. Istoricheskii roman Val'tera Skotta (A historical novel by Walter Scott). Moscow: Izd-vo Khudozh. lit., 1965, 240 p.
Perevezentseva A. Yu. Vestnik, 2011, No. 6–2. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/razvitie-istoricheskoy-prozy-v-angliyskoy-literature-hh-veka (June 22, 2024).
Proskurnin B. M. Filologicheskii klass, 2016, No. 2(44), pp. 77–83.
Reizov B. G. Istoriya i vymysel v romanakh Val'tera Skotta (History and fiction in the novels of Walter Scott). Moscow, 1971, 311 p.
Reizov B. G. Tvorchestvo Val'tera Skotta (The work of Walter Scott). Moscow; Leningrad: Khudozh. lit., 1965, 497 p.
Rogachevskaya M. S. Bibleiskie batalii v epokhu korolya Genrikha VIII (Biblical battles in the era of King Henry VIII). Minsk: MGLU, 2020, 201 p.
Rogachevskaya M. S. Yazykovaya lichnost' i effektivnaya kommunikatsiya v sovremennom polikul'turnom mire: materialy VII Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf., posvyashch. pamyati D. O. Polovtseva. Minsk, October 28–29, 2021, pp. 32–36.
Zhachemukova B. M., Beshukova F. B. Vestnik, 2011, No. 1. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/hudozhestvennaya-spetsifika-zhanra-istoricheskogo-romana (June 20, 2024).
Zinov'eva K. A. Vestnik, 2023, No. 1. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sistemy-tsennostey-v-romane-vulfholl-hmantel (June 19, 2024).
Authors
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Licensed under the Creative
Commons Attribution International License
(CC BY 4.0).
Copyright © by author(s).